Proposition 187: Dont Mess With Texas :: essays research papers

advise 187 Dont Mess With Texas     In November of 1994, atomic number 20ns passed the most controversial piece of press out enactment this decade. marriage proposal 187 was designed to stem the flow of contraband aliens into California by withholding all non-emergency medical benefitsfrom non-naturalized citizens. Latinos turned out in recruit numbers to voicetheir disapproval, and for good reason too. The wellness heraldic bearing resolutions ofProposition 187 were products of poor reason and unsound economic judgment. Theresolutions did not get the state any closer to a balanced budget, and onlyserved to worsen the health make out outlook for the future of California. It isclear that Proposition 187 was a mistake, and should not be encouraged to berepeated in Texas.     The most pop reason for passage, that supporters of Proposition 187 utilize, was the theory that a cut in vile health services would save statetaxpayers several mi llion dollars a year. This argument only applies to statesthat have a personal income tax, often used to help fund health care for thestate, and when the illegal immigrants avoid gainful this tax. Texas does nothave such a tax, so health care is funded by the taxes that everyone in thestate pays. That means that illegal aliens are gainful just as much as "realAmericans" are in sales taxes, gas taxes, liquor taxes, and cigarette taxes. Forexample, illegal aliens in San Diego, California accounted for 26.6 milliondollars in health care costs in 1994 (Serb 63). non a single person would denythat this is a lot of money, and therefore would seem to be an excellent reasonto cut funding set this minute. However, the logical person has to realizehow important those same aliens are to make full the states excise tax cofferseach year. Excise taxes paid by illegals were news report for up 60.5 millionin state tax alone (63). In retrospect, it hardly seems right to say thatillega l immigrants are not give their fair tax share for their health motivatings.It also isnt fair that "U.S. businesses need Mexican workers for low-payingjobs, precisely dont want them to have access to heath care while they are here"(Hudson 37).     Another economically based reason, that proponents of 187-likelegislation have made, is that Texans will save money by denying non-emergencycare to illegal aliens. Without close scrutiny, this seems to be a claim to makethe pocket intelligence happy. After all, we would still allow the aliens the rightto life saving treatments, but we would also save a bundle by cutting the pocketablevisits to the doctor for fevers, colds, and sprained ankles.